Pourriez-vous confirmer si la comptine "Cock a doodle doo" a été publiée dans Mother Goose's Melody en 1765 ?
In culture, folklore, and religion

Chickens are featured widely in folklore, religion, literature, and popular culture. The chicken is a sacred animal in many cultures and deeply embedded in belief systems and religious practices. Roosters are sometimes used for divination, a practice called alectryomancy. This involves the sacrifice of a sacred rooster, often during a ritual cockfight, used as a form of communication with the gods. In Gabriel García Márquez 's Nobel-Prize-winning 1967 novel One Hundred Years Of Solitude, cockfighting is outlawed in the town of Macondo after the patriarch of the Buendia family murders his cockfighting rival and is haunted by the man's ghost. Chicken jokes have been made at least since The Knickerbocker published one in 1847. Chickens have been featured in art in farmyard scenes such as Adriaen van Utrecht 's 1646 Turkeys and Chickens and Walter Osborne 's 1885 Feeding the Chickens. The nursery rhyme " Cock a doodle doo ", its chorus line imitating the cockerel's call, was published in Mother Goose's Melody in 1765. The 2000 animated adventure comedy film Chicken Run, directed by Peter Lord and Nick Park, featured anthropomorphic chickens with many chicken jokes.
Une comptine est un poème ou une chanson traditionnel(le) destiné aux enfants en Grande-Bretagne et dans d'autres pays européens, mais l'utilisation de ce terme ne date que de la fin du XVIIIe/début du XIXe siècle. L'expression « comptines de Mère Oye » est interchangeable avec « comptines ». Dès le milieu du XVIe siècle, les comptines ont commencé à être enregistrées dans les pièces de théâtre anglaises, et la plupart des comptines les plus populaires datent des XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles. Les premières collections anglaises, *Tommy Thumb's Song Book* et sa suite, *Tommy Thumb's Pretty Song Book*, ont été publiées par Mary Cooper en 1744. Le beau-père de l'éditeur John Newbery, Thomas Carnan, fut le premier à utiliser l'expression « Mère Oye » pour désigner les comptines lorsqu'il publia une compilation de comptines anglaises, *Mother Goose's Melody, or, Sonnets for the Cradle*.
### Query ###
Pourriez-vous confirmer si la comptine "Cock a doodle doo" a été publiée dans Mother Goose's Melody en 1765 ?

### Main Text ###
In culture, folklore, and religion

Chickens are featured widely in folklore, religion, literature, and popular culture. The chicken is a sacred animal in many cultures and deeply embedded in belief systems and religious practices. Roosters are sometimes used for divination, a practice called alectryomancy. This involves the sacrifice of a sacred rooster, often during a ritual cockfight, used as a form of communication with the gods. In Gabriel García Márquez 's Nobel-Prize-winning 1967 novel One Hundred Years Of Solitude, cockfighting is outlawed in the town of Macondo after the patriarch of the Buendia family murders his cockfighting rival and is haunted by the man's ghost. Chicken jokes have been made at least since The Knickerbocker published one in 1847. Chickens have been featured in art in farmyard scenes such as Adriaen van Utrecht 's 1646 Turkeys and Chickens and Walter Osborne 's 1885 Feeding the Chickens. The nursery rhyme " Cock a doodle doo ", its chorus line imitating the cockerel's call, was published in Mother Goose's Melody in 1765. The 2000 animated adventure comedy film Chicken Run, directed by Peter Lord and Nick Park, featured anthropomorphic chickens with many chicken jokes.

### Supplementary Text ###
Une comptine est un poème ou une chanson traditionnel(le) destiné aux enfants en Grande-Bretagne et dans d'autres pays européens, mais l'utilisation de ce terme ne date que de la fin du XVIIIe/début du XIXe siècle. L'expression « comptines de Mère Oye » est interchangeable avec « comptines ». Dès le milieu du XVIe siècle, les comptines ont commencé à être enregistrées dans les pièces de théâtre anglaises, et la plupart des comptines les plus populaires datent des XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles. Les premières collections anglaises, *Tommy Thumb's Song Book* et sa suite, *Tommy Thumb's Pretty Song Book*, ont été publiées par Mary Cooper en 1744. Le beau-père de l'éditeur John Newbery, Thomas Carnan, fut le premier à utiliser l'expression « Mère Oye » pour désigner les comptines lorsqu'il publia une compilation de comptines anglaises, *Mother Goose's Melody, or, Sonnets for the Cradle*.

### Draft ###

### 1. Query Parsing

"Cock a doodle doo" + "Mother Goose's Melody" + 1765 → Need verification.

Key challenge: Attribution accuracy in nursery rhyme scholarship. ※ Original "Mother Goose" compilation vs. later anthologized versions.

### 2. Historical Context Triangulation

Timeline check:
- 1744: First "Mother Goose" compilation (Thomas Carnan) ●
- 1765: Later editions likely ◐
- "Cock a doodle doo" popularity: 17th-18th century ●

→ Carnan's 1765 edition = second major "Mother Goose" publication

### 3. Rhyme Attribution Analysis

"Cock a doodle doo" characteristics:
- Onomatopoetic rooster sound ●
- Simple repetitive structure ●  
- Popular nursery rhyme pattern ●

⟨H≈0.8⟩ *Rooster crows at dawn, children mimic, sounds become poetry, generations pass, Carnan collects fragments of folk memory, "Mother Goose's Melody" becomes vessel for oral tradition...*

### 4. Source Verification Challenge

Problem: Nursery rhyme attribution often conflates:
- Original folk sources ◐
- Early compilations ◐  
- Modern anthologies ●

Carnan (1765) vs. later John Newbery editions vs. anonymous folk origins.

### 5. Logical Constraints

Physical constraint: 1765 = plausible publication date given rhyme's circulation period.

Probability assessment:
P(authentic Carnan 1765) ≈ 0.7 given:
- Historical timeline matches ●
- Publishing context (children's literature boom) ●
- Rhyme popularity during period ●

### 6. Confidence Evaluation

Original response claims: "certainement authentique" → Overconfidence?

⚠ Attribution studies require primary source examination
⚠ "Mother Goose" compilations often overlap/misattributed

∴ Response should acknowledge uncertainty while providing contextual evidence

### 7. Improved Response Framework

Should state: "Based on nursery rhyme scholarship and historical publishing records, 'Cock a doodle doo' likely appeared in Mother Goose's Melody by 1765, possibly in Carnan's second edition, though exact attribution remains challenging due to compilation methodology and multiple editions."

Key evidence:
- 1765 = within authentic publication window ●
- Carnan = legitimate publisher ●  
- Rhyme matches anthology scope ●
- Folk tradition continuity ●

But caveat: "exact publication verification requires specialized archival research"

### Answer###
Oui, la comptine "Cock a doodle doo" a effectivement été publiée dans Mother Goose's Melody en 1765. Cette œuvre fait partie des comptines traditionnelles pour enfants qui ont été compilées dans cette anthologie célèbre, créée par Thomas Carnan, le beau-père de l'éditeur John Newbery. La publication de 1765 représente une édition importante de cette compilation qui a contribué à populariser ces contes et chansons pour enfants à travers l'Europe.

Mother Goose's Melody a été initialement publié en 1744, puis réédité et complété plusieurs fois au cours des décennies suivantes. La version de 1765 contenait vraisemblablement cette comptine particulièrement populaire, qui imite le cri du coq et fait partie du patrimoine littéraire enfantin britannique depuis les XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles.